Sulawesi or Bali, Java, Sumatra, Lombok, Flores or Borneo? Choosing an Indonesian Island

How Sulawesi compares with Bali, Java, Sumatra, Lombok, Flores and Borneo for culture, diving, wildlife and ease of travel.

  • Places
  • 10 min read

Sulawesi suits travellers who want culture (Tana Toraja funerals and tongkonan houses), serious diving (the walls of Bunaken, the muck of Lembeh, the reefs of Wakatobi), endemic wildlife (anoa, babirusa, tarsiers, the maleo) and strong regional food. It suits first-time visitors who want easy travel less well. Choose Bali for that, Lombok or the Gili Islands for a simple beach trip, and Sumatra or Borneo for orangutans. Sulawesi pairs well with Java or Bali on a longer trip.

Each Indonesian island gives a different kind of holiday:

  • Bali: resorts and cocktails.
  • Java: culture and volcanoes.
  • Sumatra: orangutans and wilder forest.
  • Lombok: a gentler version of Bali.
  • Flores: Komodo dragons and boat trips from Labuan Bajo.
  • Borneo: forest wildlife.

Sulawesi does not fit any of these labels. Here is how it compares.

Who Sulawesi suits

A strong choice for:

  • Travellers who put culture first, above all in Tana Toraja.
  • Serious divers, at Wakatobi, Lembeh and Bunaken.
  • Wildlife lovers who want species found nowhere else.
  • Food lovers. Each region has its own strong cuisine.
  • Repeat visitors to Indonesia who want something truly unlike Bali.

A weaker choice for:

  • A first trip to Indonesia with simple logistics. Bali or Java is easier.
  • A pure beach holiday. Bali, Lombok and the Gili Islands are simpler.
  • Orangutans. Go to Sumatra or Borneo.
  • Many volcano hikes. Java has more.
  • Komodo dragons. These live in Flores, of course.

Bali

People ask about this comparison most.

Bali is better forSulawesi is better for
Hotels, restaurants and transportLiving culture: Toraja, against the staged "cultural tourism" of parts of Bali
Tourism in EnglishDiving: Bunaken and Wakatobi against Bali's ordinary reefs
Beach and cocktail holidaysSpace: Sulawesi has few visitors, Bali has too many
Yoga and wellnessFood that locals eat
Real surfPrice: usually cheaper for the same quality
Direct international flights. Sulawesi needs a change, usually through Makassar or Manado

Our advice: for a first, short trip to Indonesia, choose Bali. For a second trip, or for a clear interest in culture or diving, choose Sulawesi.

Java

The two islands are very different, so the comparison is loose.

Java is better forSulawesi is better for
Great archaeological sites: Borobudur, PrambananDiving
Big-city life: Yogyakarta, JakartaEndemic wildlife
Trains across the islandTana Toraja
Many cultures within a short distanceFewer visitors
Easy trips to Mount Bromo and Ijen

Our advice: choose Java for archaeology and famous cultural sites. Choose Sulawesi for culture and wildlife together. Both are good, and they work well together on a long trip.

Sumatra

Of all the islands, Sumatra is closest to Sulawesi as a quieter option than Bali.

Sumatra is better forSulawesi is better for
Orangutans: Bukit Lawang, Tangkahan, Gunung LeuserDiving
Forest wildlife in generalTana Toraja, which has no match in Sumatra
Lake Toba, one of the great crater lakes of the worldLower malaria risk, depending on the part of Sumatra
Surfing in the Mentawai IslandsEasier travel. Sumatra is larger and harder to cross

Our advice: go to Sumatra for orangutans and forest, and to Sulawesi for diving and Toraja. Neither is on the main tourist trail. Both repay travellers who make the effort.

Lombok

Many people sell Lombok as Bali without the crowds.

Lombok is better forSulawesi is better for
Easier travel than SulawesiDepth of culture
The Mount Rinjani trekDiving
Easy island hopping in the Gili IslandsEndemic wildlife
A short ferry from BaliReal quiet. Lombok is building fast, Sulawesi is not

Our advice: Lombok suits an easy beach trip near Bali. Sulawesi suits travellers ready to commit to a bigger destination.

Flores

Both are quieter choices in eastern Indonesia.

Flores is better forSulawesi is better for
Komodo dragons, the main reason to goCulture. Manggarai and Bajawa in Flores are interesting, but Toraja has more
Boat trips from Labuan Bajo through Komodo National ParkReef diving. Bunaken equals Komodo without the strong currents
Easy diving access in Komodo watersSize and variety
More mid-range tourist services than parts of Sulawesi

Our advice: pick Flores for Komodo and a short boat trip, and Sulawesi for a broader journey. You can join the two: fly Bali to Flores to Sulawesi, or the other way round.

Borneo (Kalimantan)

Borneo is the other wild-forest choice.

Borneo is better forSulawesi is better for
Huge forests, far larger than Sulawesi'sDiving. Borneo's reefs are ordinary beside Bunaken or Wakatobi
Orangutans: Tanjung Puting, Kutai and the wider forestRange of cultures. Sulawesi has Toraja, Bugis, Bajau, Mandar and Minahasan peoples. Borneo has the Dayak
River trips on the Mahakam and the KapuasEasier access. Sulawesi's airports are better developed than most in Borneo
A wilder feel for adventurous travellers

Our advice: Borneo for orangutans and forest animals. Sulawesi for diving and a wider range of cultures.

What only Sulawesi has

Some things you cannot find anywhere else in Indonesia:

  • Bugis and Makassar sea culture. Pinisi boat building at Tana Beru, the Bugis tradition of sailing and the wider story of Indonesian seafaring.
  • Toraja funerals. The Rambu Solo' ceremony has no equal in Indonesia.
  • Walls and muck in one trip. Bunaken and Lembeh together form one of the strongest dive pairs in the world.
  • Minahasan food. It tastes like nothing else in the country.
  • Wallace's Line. Sulawesi is the leading destination in Wallacea. You cannot see the anoa, the babirusa, its tarsiers or its endemic birds anywhere else.
  • The bissu. In Pangkep, a few of these Bugis priests still practise, though their number is falling.

For the right traveller, these are the reasons to come.

Combining islands on a 3 to 4 week trip

The classic, 4 weeks

  • Bali, 1 week: arrival and rest.
  • Java, 1 week: Yogyakarta, Borobudur, Ijen.
  • Sulawesi, 2 weeks: Toraja, Bira, Bunaken.

Culture and wildlife, 3 weeks

  • Sumatra, 1 week: orangutans and Lake Toba.
  • Sulawesi, 2 weeks: Toraja, Bunaken, Lembeh.

Diving, 3 weeks

  • Komodo, Flores, 1 week.
  • Sulawesi, 2 weeks: Bunaken, Lembeh, Wakatobi.

Sulawesi works just as well inside a longer trip as on its own.

The bottom line

Sulawesi is not Bali. Services are thinner, travel takes more effort, and outside the big cities fewer people speak English. In return, the trip has more substance: deep culture, wildlife, real local food and excellent diving. You come home feeling you went somewhere, not to a resort that could be anywhere.

Matched with the right traveller, Sulawesi ranks among the best places in Indonesia. For the wrong one, the effort outweighs the reward. Decide which traveller you are, and the choice becomes clear.